By Lee Berthiaume, The Canadian Press
Wed Sep 09 2020 18:33
OTTAWA — WE Charity says it is closing its Canadian operations, blaming COVID−19 and the political fallout from the Liberal government’s plan to have it run a multimillion−dollar student−volunteer program for leaving it in financial ruin.
Craig and Marc Kielburger, who are also planning to step down from the organization they co−founded, released an open letter Wednesday explaining the move.
“COVID−19 disrupted every aspect of our work,” the brothers wrote in the letter. “The fallout from the Canada Student Service Grant has placed us as a charity in the middle of political battles and misinformation that we are ill−equipped to fight.
“The financial math for the charity’s future is clear.”
The Toronto−based youth organization shared the news with its Canadian−based staff on Wednesday.
WE’s operations in Britain and the U.S will not be immediately affected. Neither will its for−profit affiliate, ME to WE, which makes money through leadership courses, retail sales and travel programs.
The move represents a stunning fall for the charity, which the Kielburgers first created in 1995 as a way for youth in Canada to help less−fortunate kids around the world.
Few could have foreseen the degree to which the government’s spring decision to have WE administer the now−defunct student grant program would hurt both the Liberals and the charity.
The deal would have seen WE paid up to $43.5 million to run the program. The federal government had budgeted $912 million for the program, which was designed to cover up to $5,000 in education costs for students who volunteered during the COVID−19 pandemic. The sole−sourced contract with WE pegged the cost at $543 million and stipulated the organization would not make money on the deal.
News of the deal prompted immediate questions about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s ties to WE. The controversy has since expanded to include former finance minister Bill Morneau. Both face investigations by the federal ethics watchdog into whether they violated the Conflict of Interest Act. Both have apologized for not recusing themselves from the decision to award WE the contract.
A spokesman for Trudeau declined to comment on the news Wednesday. A spokeswoman for Youth Minister Bardish Chagger, who was responsible for the program, also declined comment.
WE backed out of the deal in early July, citing the political controversy. Many of its corporate sponsors eventually cut ties with the organization at a time when it was already struggling to make ends meet because of the pandemic−related shutdown.
WE says it plans to lay off 115 Canadian staff and sell all its property in Canada in the coming months, including its landmark $15−million Global Learning Centre in downtown Toronto, which opened in 2017.
It follows news last month that WE would be laying off dozens of employees in Canada and the United Kingdom. At the time, WE said it would assess its real estate holdings but planned to keep its headquarters in Toronto.
The net profits will be put in an endowment fund that will be overseen by a new board of governors and used to complete several projects in communities in Latin America, Asia and Africa that were started by WE but remain unfinished.
The fund will also cover the operating costs of several large−scale infrastructure projects, such as a hospital and college in Kenya and an agricultural centre in Ecuador. However, no new projects or programs will be launched.
All future WE Day events are also being cancelled while the organization says it will no longer have staff to work with teachers, though existing resources will be digitized and available online. WE says it was active in 7,000 schools across Canada.
“Without decisive action, WE Charity’s ongoing costs to operate in Canada would exceed revenue and consume savings that are essential to establish the endowment fund,” wrote the Kielburgers, who plan to leave after the transition is finished.
“We calculate that this action preserves as many humanitarian and educational programs as possible, for as long as possible. Putting children first means prioritizing them above the charity. This is a heartbreaking decision.”
Asked who will oversee the sale of the charity’s property, WE executive director Dalal Al−Waheidi said in a statement that a special committee of the board of directors comprised of individuals with legal, financial and property experience will be responsible.
“One hundred per cent of all proceeds will be directed to the charity and/or towards the formation of the future charitable endowment,” she added. “For the sake of absolute clarity, no individual(s) will benefit in any way from the transactions.”
New Democrat MP Charlie Angus said the shutdown of WE’s Canadian operations demonstrates that the charity was in a precarious financial position even before the controversy.
“What we’ve learned from our parliamentary investigation is that this was an organization that had grown very quickly, really over−extended themselves and were in economic free fall,” Angus said, accusing WE of being “desperate to play on their links to the Trudeau family.”
WE has returned the $30 the government paid it to launch the program and has said it won’t ask to be reimbursed for roughly $5 million in expenses.
The question of how and why WE was selected to run the Canada Student Service Grant is expected to feature prominently when the House of Commons returns on Sept. 23, after Trudeau prorogued Parliament last month.
The Liberals insist the charity was recommended by the non−partisan public service, but thousands of documents released by the government last month suggested bureaucrats may have been pushed in that direction by their political masters.
Much of the focus has been around the ties that Trudeau and his family have to WE. The prime minister has been a featured speaker at six WE Day rallies while his wife, mother and brother have all received money from the organization.
Several parliamentary committees launched investigations into the deal over the summer, but they were halted because of prorogation. Opposition parties have promised to resume those studies when Parliament returns.
Shortly after WE’s announcement Wednesday, Conservative Leader Erin O’Toole tweeted: “WE must immediately release the documents that the Finance Committee requested on their involvement in Justin Trudeau’s $900 million scandal.”
In testimony to the finance committee in July, the Kielburgers said they agreed to run the grant program to help Canadian students, adding that if they’d known how things would have played out, they wouldn’t have answered the government’s phone call.
Wiki Production Code: A0153